|
Indian Pediatr 2017;54: 451-452 |
 |
Quality, Equity and Dignity for Preterm
Infants Through Family-centered Care
|
Anthony Costello
Director, Department of Maternal, Child and
Adolescent Health, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Email: [email protected]
|
B onding’ between a mother and her newborn infant
was a concept first described by DW Winnicott, the pediatrician turned
psychoanalyst. In the 1970s and 1980s, Marshal Klaus and John Kennell in
the USA, and Martin Richards, Cliff Roberton and Freddie Brimblecombe in
the UK, raised the idea that mother-infant attachment and bonding in the
early newborn period was of critical importance, especially for preterm
infants [1]. Any period of separation between mother and infant,
especially in an intensive care unit, might be traumatic to bonding, and
have long-term consequences for the mother-baby relationship. Even a
brief period of separation might set up a vicious circle of effects
where poor interaction would lead to accumulating problems for the
relationship. Others felt this was too strict a concept; the effects of
separation depended upon the perception of the mother, the circumstances
of illness, and took no account of the considerable powers of resilience
and recovery by mothers.
Periods of separation certainly affect the onset of
lactation and impairment of infant growth in low-resource communities,
and increase the risk of maternal depression and child abuse in the
years ahead [2]. Being born too soon also means that a mother’s
psychological preparation for motherhood is cut short, which might make
her more vulnerable to the effects of separation. The crisis of having a
sick preterm baby may make her and her partner feel depressed, intensely
anxious, and create irrational fears about malformations. And where
babies clearly do face long-term problems, parents require time and
support to cope with this ‘bereavement.’ Conversely, a recent trial in
India showed that attachment scores were one-third higher among low
birth weight infants where the close maternal contact from kangaroo
mother care was practised for six hours or more each day [3]. Even with
intact preterm infants though, neurological immaturity means their
interaction and ‘dialogue’ with a parent is blunted, so they are in some
ways less satisfying and rewarding than term babies. Martin Richards,
after observing the practice of multiple caregiving by many different
nurses in UK neonatal units, wrote: "a prime aim of neonatal care must
be to provide a peaceful and calm atmosphere in which parents get to
know their infants."
Recently, I visited the neonatal unit in RML
Hospital, Delhi where Professor Arti Maria and her team practise ‘family
centered care’ (FCC), which they have evaluated through a randomized
controlled trial [4]. In their study, they randomized 295 neonates at
the time of hospitalization in neonatal intensive care unit to either
the control group (n=147) or intervention group (n=148).
Intervention involved training of the ‘parent-attendant’ in neonatal
care using an indigenously developed and pretested, culturally
sensitive, simple audio-video tool that covered domains of personal
hygiene, hand washing, danger signs recognition and feeding of sick
neonate. Control group received routine care by nurse-doctor. They
reported a comparable incidence of nosocomial episodes of sepsis in both
groups. However, the pre-discharge exclusive breastfeeding rates were
significantly higher in intervention group.
The idea of FCC is simple – to involve parents at all
times in the care of their sick newborns, not only to improve
survival but also to respond to their needs and rights as parents. From
the moment the infant is admitted to the unit, parents are offered
training in basic nursing skills to feed, clean, clothe and monitor
their baby. Both mother and father can enjoy continuous access to babies
in equal partnership with the nursing staff. By enhancing competencies
of parents, FCC builds a continuum of care from hospital to home, and
makes for better preventive health and survival after discharge. What
struck me most was the calm atmosphere of the unit as four mother
‘nurses’, in blue gowns and masks, stood by open cots under radiant
warmers and caressed or cooed to their baby to start a crucial dialogue
that would establish a lifetime of loving care. The environment is
develop-mentally supportive for the sick baby, culturally sensitive, and
wonderfully responsive to the emotional needs of worried parents. It
also supplements a shortage of nursing power within the nursery.
Readers of this journal need no reminder of the
burden of newborn death and disability in India. Almost 25 million
infants are born each year, of whom perhaps 3 to 4 million will be born
too soon or face sickness soon after birth. Around half of all child
deaths occur at this time. And the trend toward urbanization – from
extended to nuclear families, with both parents often forced to work –
means that bonding and secure attachments for young children are of even
greater importance. Most people in India use public sector facilities
where staffing ratios are low; so this approach has great economic value
in the short-term, although training and support for parents does
require additional time inputs from staff. FCC can therefore benefit the
poorest and most vulnerable by judicious use of spare hands. It might
also improve gender equality by involving both mothers and fathers
equally in the care of their precious newborn baby. Children whose
fathers are more positively engaged with them at the age of three months
have fewer behavioral problems at the age of twelve months [5].
Above all, FCC is participatory and respectful, and
provides mothers and fathers with dignity at a time when they are most
vulnerable. I met with several families in Delhi whose infants had gone
home after FCC, and there was unanimity in the appreciation they gave to
this method. Adopted with overwhelming support by Member States at the
World Health Assembly in May 2016, the Framework on Integrated
people-centered health services (IPCHS) aims for a fundamental shift
in the way health services are funded, managed and delivered [6].
Responsiveness and participation are key elements so that care is
coordinated around people’s needs, respects their preferences, and
allows for people’s participation in health affairs. In February 2017 in
Malawi, WHO and UNICEF assisted nine countries, including India, to
launch a Network for Improving Quality of Care for Maternal, Newborn and
Child Health to cut preventable maternal and newborn illness and deaths,
and to improve every mother’s experience of care [7]. FCC, along the
lines of the model developed by the Delhi team, is an important way to
link quality, equity and dignity for newborns.
Only time will tell the extent to which FCC has a
positive impact on future child development and the next generation,
especially when facilities and staffing are sub-optimal. A working
hypothesis is that exclusive breastfeeding, better hygienic practices,
less infection and emotional attachment might all be longer lasting
benefits. Follow-up studies of the FCC cohorts will be important. And
evaluation of the method at scale is an implementation science question
of some importance, in order to show that successful pilot studies in
tertiary centers are not attenuated when scaled up through district
facilities.
Funding: None; Competing interests: None
stated.
References
1. Klaus M, Kennell J, Klaus P. Bonding: Building the
foundation of a secure attachment and independence. Reading,
Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass, USA, 1995.
2. Flacking R, Lehtonen L, Thomson G, Axelin A,
Ahlqvist S, Moran VH, et al. Closeness and separation in neonatal
intensive care. Acta Paediatr. 2012;101:1032-7.
3. Gathwala G, Singh B, Balhara B. KMC facilitates
mother baby attachment in low birth weight infants. Indian J Pediatr.
2008;75:43-7.
4. Verma A, Maria A, Pandey RM, Hans C, Verma A,
Sherwani F. Family-centered care to complement care of sick newborns: A
randomized controlled trial. Indian Pediatr. 2017;54:455-9.
5. Ramchandani PG, Domoney J, Sethna V, Psychogiou L,
Vlachos H, Murray L. Do early father-infant interactions predict the
onset of externalising behaviours in young children? Findings from a
longitudinal cohort study. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2013;54:56-64.
6. World Health Organization. WHO Framework on
Integrated People-centred Health Services. Available from:
http://www.who.int/servicedeliverysafety/areas/people-centred-care/framework/en/.
Accessed May 19, 2017.
7. World Health Organization. Maternal, Newborn,
Child and Adolescent Health. Quality of Care. Available from: http://www.who.int/maternal_child_adolescent/topics/quality-of-care/en/.
Accessed May 19, 2017.
|
|
 |
|