|
Indian Pediatr 2018;55: 35-37 |
 |
Comparison of Scrub
Typhus Meningitis with Acute Bacterial Meningitis and
Tuberculous Meningitis
|
SVAS Raju Kakarlapudi 1,
Anila Chacko1,
Prasanna Samuel2,
Valsan Philip Verghese1
and Winsley Rose1
From Departments of 1Paediatrics and
2Biostatistics, Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu,
India.
Correspondence to: Dr. Winsley Rose, Professor,
Department of Paediatrics, Christian Medical College, Vellore 632004,
Tamilnadu, India.
Email:
[email protected]
Received: November 05, 2016;
Initial review: November 21, 2016;
Accepted: September 29, 2017.
|
Objective: To compare scrub
typhus meningitis with bacterial and tuberculous meningitis. Methods:
Children aged<15 years admitted with meningitis were screened and
those who fit criteria for diagnosis of scrub typhus meningitis (n=48),
bacterial meningitis (n=44) and tuberculous meningitis (n=31)
were included for analysis. Clinical features, investigations and
outcomes were compared between the three types of meningitis.
Results: Mean age, duration of fever at presentation, presence of
headache and, altered sensorium and presence of hepatomegaly/splenomegaly
were statistically significantly different between the groups. Scrub
typhus had statistically significant thrombocytopenia, shorter hospital
stay and a better neurological and mortality outcome. Conclusions:
Sub-acute presentation of meningitis in older age group children,
and good outcome is associated with scrub typhus when compared to
bacterial and tuberculous meningitis.
Keywords: Encephalopathy, Outcome,
Presentation, Rickettsial infections.
|
M eningitis in children is a serious illness with
20% mortality [1] and 20% long term sequelae in childhood bacterial
meningitis [2]; and 20% mortality and 54% neurological sequelae in
tuberculous meningitis [3]. Scrub typhus meningitis has negligible
mortality or sequelae and occurs in about 25% patients with scrub typhus
[4,5]. Making a definite diagnosis of scrub typhus can be challenging
and requires a high index of suspicion [6,7]. In this retrospective
study, we compared the clinical features, investigations and outcome of
scrub typhus meningitis (STM) with acute bacterial meningitis (ABM) and
tuberculous meningitis (TBM).
Methods
After Institutional review board approval, We
retrospectively reviewed and analyzed the records of all children aged
<15 years admitted under the Department of Pediatrics at the Christian
Medical College, Vellore hospital with scrub typhus meningitis,
bacterial meningitis, and probable/confirmed tuberculous meningitis
between January 2010 and December 2014. Scrub typhus meningitis was
defined as fever with CSF pleocytosis (CSF WBC count >5 cells/µL) and
positive IgM using the InBios Scrub Typhus Detect IgM ELISA kit (manu-facturer)
or a positive Weil Felix test with an OX K titre
³80 in blood.
Bacterial meningitis was defined as any child with fever, CSF
pleocytosis (CSF WBC count >5 cells/µL) and positive CSF or blood
culture for bacteria other than Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
or positive Latex agglutination test PCR for bacteria in the CSF.
Tuberculous meningitis was included if the patients fit the criteria for
definite or probable tuberculous meningitis [8]. Clinical features,
investigations and outcome were compared between scrub typhus meningitis
and bacterial and tuberculous meningitis. Statistical analysis was
performed using STATA 13.
Results
There were 48 STM, 44 ABM and 31 TBM cases during the
study period. In those with STM, 23 were positive by Weil Felix test, 15
by Scrub IgM ELISA and 10 were positive by both. Eleven (22.9%) of the
patients with STM had eschar. Of those with bacterial meningitis, the
causative organisms were Streptococcus pneumoniae in 22 (50%),
Hemophilus influenzae in 11 (25%), non-typhoidal Salmonella in 3
(6.8%), Enterococcus spp. and Neisseria meningitides in 2
(4.5%) each, and S. agalactiae, S. pyogenes, Burkholderia
pseudomalleii and Acinetobacter baumannii in one each.
Definite tuberculous meningitis was diagnosed in 13 (41.9%) and probable
tuberculous meningitis in 18 (58.1%).
Comparative data on the demographic, clinical,
investigations and outcome parameters is shown in Table I.
Children with STM were considerably older (mean 9.12 years) than ABM
(mean 3.1 years) or TBM (mean 6.36 years). Most children (83.3%) with
STM presented with 4-10 days of fever, while children with ABM presented
earlier (50% within 3 days of fever) and children with TBM later (80.7%
over 10 days of fever). Splenomegaly was more common with STM, and
hepatomegaly with ABM and TBM. Among the blood investigations,
thrombocytopenia showed a strong association with scrub typhus.
TABLE I Demographic, Clinical and Outcome Parameters in Children With Three Types of Meningitis (N=123)
Parameters |
STM |
ABM |
STM vs ABM |
TBM |
STM vs TBM |
|
(n=48) |
(n=44) |
OR (95% CI) |
(n=31) |
OR (95% CI) |
Mean age (SD), y |
9.12 (3.77) |
3.1(4.28) |
- |
6.36(4.78) |
- |
Fever |
|
|
|
|
|
<3 days, n (%) |
2 (4.2) |
22 (50) |
|
1 (3.2) |
|
4-10 days, n (%) |
40 (83.3) |
14 (31.8) |
31.4 (6.5,151.11) |
5 (16.1) |
4 (0.3,52.5) |
>10 days, n (%) |
6 (12.5) |
8 (18.2) |
8.2 (1.4,49.6) |
25 (80.7) |
0.12 (0.009,1.6) |
Headache, n (%) |
29 (60.4) |
8 (18.2) |
6.87 (2.63, 17.94) |
17 (54.8) |
1.26 (0.50,3.13) |
Altered Sensorium, n (%) |
23 (47.9) |
29 (65.9) |
0.48 (0.21,1.10) |
24 (80.0) |
0.23 (0.08, 0.66) |
Seizures, n (%) |
20 (41.7) |
28 (63.6) |
0.41 (0.18,0.95) |
17 (56.7) |
0.55 (0.22,1.37) |
Breathing difficulty, n (%) |
1 (2.1) |
4 (9.1) |
0.21(0.02, 1.98) |
0 |
- |
Abdominal, pain, n (%) |
9 (19.1) |
3 (7.0) |
3.16 (0.79, 12.55) |
1 (3.2) |
7.11 (0.85,59.23) |
Rash, n (%) |
4 (8.3) |
1 (2.3) |
0.99 (0.42,36.40) |
0 |
- |
Hepatomegaly, n (%) |
22 (45.8) |
37 (84.1) |
0.16 (0.06, 0.43) |
28 (90.3) |
0.091 (0.02,0.33) |
Splenomegaly, n (%) |
27 (56.3) |
6 (13.6) |
8.14 (2.90,22.87) |
3 (9.7) |
12.0 (3.2-44.9) |
Platelet count >150,000/µL, n (%) |
17 (35.4) |
34 (77.3) |
0.16 (0.06,0.41) |
30(96.8) |
0.02 (0.002,0.15) |
Median (IQR) CSF WBC count |
50.0 [25.0;105] |
510 [111;1698] |
- |
80.0 [22.0;160] |
- |
Mean (SD) CSF Protein, mg% |
78.7 (43.3) |
235 (308) |
- |
142 (104) |
- |
Mean (SD) CSF Glucose, mg% |
39.0 (9.69) |
23.7 (16.1) |
- |
25.2 (15.0) |
- |
Hospitalization, d, mean (SD) |
5.81 (2.27) |
9.59 (6.51) |
- |
12.9 (10.8) |
- |
Duration of ventilation, d, mean (SD) |
4.33 (2.08) |
8.4 (6.35) |
- |
5 (1.41) |
- |
Death/premature discharge likely causing death, n (%) |
0 |
5 (11.4) |
- |
3 (9.6) |
- |
Neurological deficits, n (%) |
0 |
4 (4.6) |
- |
17 (54.8) |
- |
CSF: cerebrospinal fluid; WBC: white blood cell; STM: Scrub
typhus meningitis; ABM: acute bacterial meningitis; TBM:
tubercular meningitis. |
STM had a significantly shorter hospital stay and
better outcome (less death/premature discharge likely to have caused
death and neurological deficits). Children with scrub typhus were
treated with doxycycline alone in 18 (37.5%), azithromycin alone in 3
(6.3%), chloram-phenicol alone in 3 (6.3%), doxycycline and azithromycin
in 20 (41.7%), doxycycline and chloramphenicol in 2 (4.2%), azithromycin
and chloramphenicol in 1 (2.1%) and doxycycline, azithromycin and
chloramphenicol in 1 (2.1%).
Discussion
Important differences in clinical features (age of
presentation, duration of fever and presence of liver or spleen
enlargement) between the three types (STM, ABM, and TBM) were observed
in this study.
The association between older children and scrub
typhus meningitis is similar to that reported by Bhat, et al.
(mean age of 8 years) [5]. Bacterial meningitis and tuberculous
meningitis have been reported in much younger children with median ages
of 6 months and 32 months, respectively [9,10]. Fever duration of 4-10
days was significantly more likely with STM in this study. Bhat, et
al.[5] and Varghese, et al. [11] reported a mean fever
duration of 7.9 days in children and 8.4 days in adults with STM,
respectively. Fever and non-specific symptoms are reported to precede
CNS manifestations in childhood tuberculosis meningitis by 13-42 days
[12] Splenic enlargement in over half of those with STM is consistent
with reported literature [5].
Among the blood counts, only thrombocytopenia was
significantly associated with scrub typhus meningitis, similar to
reports in adults [11]. CSF parameters for STM were comparable to
previous reports except for CSF glucose that was considerably lower in
our study (39 mg/dL vs 64.2 mg/dL) [5]. Children with STM had
signi-ficantly less hospital stay, and no neurological sequelae or
death. Bhat, et al. [5] too reported considerably less mortality
with STM compared to scrub typhus without meningitis [5]. This is in
contrast with the 25% mortality that has been reported in adults with
STM [11]. Eschar, a valuable clue to scrub typhus [13] was present in
23% of our patients, which is similar to reported literature [4,5].
Careful examination of the hidden skin folds of the axillae, groin and
genitalia is important. [14].
Our study has a number of limitations such as the
retrospective nature of the analysis, the convenience sample used, the
reliance on serological tests for diagnosis of scrub typhus, and the
reliance on blood serology rather than a CSF-based test for diagnosis of
STM. However, with good specificity being reported with these tests,
over-diagnosis of STM is unlikely.
In conclusion, scrub typhus meningitis is an
important cause of acute and sub-acute meningitis. In any child of older
arrange group with meningitis with a sub-acute presentation, presence of
splenic enlargement and thrombocytopenia should alert the clinician to
the possibility of scrub typhus. Finding an eschar is a valuable clue to
diagnosis of scrub typhus. Appropriate specific testing for scrub typhus
and specific antibiotic therapy results in good prognosis.
Acknowledgements: Mr E Prabhu who helped with
data collection and data entry.
Contributors:SRK: data collection, design of
study, preparation of the manuscript; AC, VPV: data interpretation,
preparation of manuscript; PS: data analysis and preparation of
manuscript; WR: conception and design of study, data analysis and
preparation of the manuscript. All authors approved the final
manuscript.
Funding: None; Competing interests: None
stated.
References
1. Brouwer MC, McIntyre P, Prasad K, van de Beek D.
Corticosteroids for acute bacterial meningitis. Cochrane Database Syst
Rev. 2015;9:CD004405.
2. Edmond K, Clark A, Korczak VS, Sanderson C,
Griffiths UK, Rudan I. Global and regional risk of disabling sequelae
from bacterial meningitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet
Infect Dis. 2010;10:317-28.
3. Chiang SS, Khan FA, Milstein MB, Tolman AW,
Benedetti A, Starke JR, et al. Treatment outcomes of childhood
tuberculous meningitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet
Infect Dis. 2014;14:947-57.
4. Viswanathan S, Muthu V, Iqbal N, Remalayam B,
George T. Scrub typhus meningitis in south India: A retrospective study.
PLoS one. 2013;8:e66595.
5. Bhat NK, Pandita N, Saini M, Dhar M, Ahmed S,
Shirazi N, et al. Scrub typhus: A clinico-laboratory
differentiation of children with and without meningitis. J Trop Pediatr.
2016;62:194-9.
6. Paris DH, Shelite TR, Day NP, Walker DH.
Unresolved problems related to scrub typhus: A seriously neglected
life-threatening disease. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2013;89:301-7.
7. Isaac R, Varghese GM, Mathai E, Manjula J, Joseph
I. Scrub typhus: prevalence and diagnostic issues in rural Southern
India. Clin Infect Dis. 2004;39:1395-6.
8. Marais S, Thwaites G, Schoeman JF, Torok ME, Misra
UK, Prasad K, et al. Tuberculous meningitis: a uniform case
definition for use in clinical research. Lancet Infect Dis.
2010;10:803-12f.
9. Nigrovic LE, Kuppermann N, Malley R, Macias JT,
Moro-Sutherland DM, Schremmer RD, et al. Children with bacterial
meningitis presenting to the emergency department during the
pneumococcal conjugate vaccine era. Acad Emerg Med. 2008;15:522-8.
10. Nabukeera-Barungi N, Wilmshurst J, Rudzani M,
Nuttall J. Presentation and outcome of tuberculous meningitis among
children: experiences from a tertiary children’s hospital. Afr Health
Sci. 2014;14:143-9.
11. Varghese GM, Mathew A, Kumar S, Abraham OC,
Trowbridge P, Mathai E. Differential diagnosis of scrub typhus
meningitis from bacterial meningitis using clinical and laboratory
features. Neurol India. 2013;61:17-20.
12. Well GTJ van, Paes BF, Terwee CB, Springer P,
Roord JJ, Donald PR, et al. Twenty years of pediatric tuberculous
meningitis: A retrospective cohort study in the western cape of South
Africa. Pediatrics. 2009;123:e1-8.
13. Kundavaram AP, Jonathan AJ, Nathaniel SD,
Varghese GM. Eschar in scrub typhus: a valuable clue to the diagnosis. J
Postgrad Med. 2013;59:177-8.
14. Rose W, Rajan RJ, Punnen A, Ghosh U. Distribution
of eschar in pediatric scrub. typhus. J Trop Pediatr. 2016;62:415-20.
|
|
 |
|