|
Indian Pediatr 2021;58: 430-435 |
 |
Effectiveness of an Educational
School-Based Intervention on Knowledge of Unintentional Injury
Prevention and First Aid Among Students in Ujjain, India
|
Saniya Mehreen, 1 Aditya
Mathur,2 Jitendra Jat,2
Ashish Pathak2
From 1Global Health—Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden; and
2Department of Pediatrics, RD Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, Madhya
Pradesh.
Correspondence to: Dr Ashish Pathak, Department of Pediatrics,
RD Gardi Medical College, Ujjain 456 006, Madhya Pradesh, India.
Email:
[email protected]
Received: June 29, 2020;
Initial review: July 20, 2020;
Accepted:
December 29, 2020.
|
Objective: To
determine the effectiveness of an educational intervention on
the knowledge of adolescents on prevention of unintentional
injuries and first aid.
Methods: The study
used one group pre-post intervention design, without external
controls. A two-stage (at schools and classes) cluster sampling
was used to enroll 1944 high school students in Ujjain district.
The intervention consisted of educational intervention using
lectures presented through Power Point presentations, pictures,
and videos. Sixty sessions each wherein a questionnaire to
assess knowledge of participants was administered before and
after the educational intervention. The outcome was a change in
knowledge score.
Results: The study
included 1944 school students [1105 (57%) boys] with mean (SD)
age of 15.9 (1.3) years. The analysis of variance revealed the
difference between the sum total of pre- and post-intervention
scores was statistically significant (P <0.001), with a
large effect size of 3.7. Younger students outperformed older
students, boys outperformed girls, students of urban schools
outperformed their rural counterparts, students of public
schools outperformed those of private schools and students of
Hindi medium schools outperformed students of English medium
schools.
Conclusions: This
school-based educational intervention significantly increased
the knowledge of students on the prevention of unintentional
injuries and first aid.
Keywords: Adolescent, Educational
intervention, Prevention.
|
I njury is a leading
cause of mortality worldwide,
more so in lower income countries and lower-middle-income countries [1-3]. The large burden of
injury and the associated mortality and morbidity are
preventable [4]. Delay in immediate and appropriate first
aid increases the mortality and morbidity due to injuries.
Trauma services and pre-hospital care are
inadequate in many parts of India [3]. Furthermore, the lack
of guidelines for pre-hospital care, sparse skilled staff
and ambulances, and the long distances to hospitals
aggravates the severity of the of injuries and road traffic
accidents [5,6]. First aid is the initial part of the
continuum of injury and trauma care, which can protect the
lives at homes, schools, workplaces, and public places.
Therefore, first aid education to lay people is needed.
The target population of the intervention
in the present study was adolescents because they are
pivotal members of the community and can act as change
agents [7]. Moreover, adolescents spend most of their time
in schools, and their active participation in sports and
other physical activities exposes them to various
unintentional injuries [7]. Therefore, creating awareness
among adolescents by imparting knowledge on injury
prevention and first aid is essential.
A systematic review from Australia
examined the breadth of first aid training delivered to
adolescent school students and identified only two studies
that focused on injury prevention and first aid measures
[7]. The efficacy of educational interventions in creating
awareness about the prevention of injuries and their first
aid among students has been reported by both teachers and
students [7]. First aid is not a part of the formal teaching
curriculum in most schools in India; therefore, this study
was planned to impart formal knowledge of first aid to
adolescents and to determine the effectiveness of the
school-based educational intervention for prevention of
unintentional injuries in improving the knowledge of
adolescents studying in schools located in a district in
Madhya Pradesh (MP), India.
METHODS
The present pre-post intervention study
without external controls was conducted on 1944 students
aged 14-20 years and studying in classes 9 to 12, from 30
schools from both rural and urban areas of Ujjain district
located in MP. The population of the district is
approximately 1.9 million, with 61% of the population
resides in rural areas having agricultural economy [8].
Children under 15 years of age constitute 28.9% of the total
population [9].
A total of 50 students were enrolled in a
pilot study to calculate sample size as there are no similar
Indian studies. Of the total questions, administered to the
participants, 48–56% were answered correctly. To maximize
the sample size, the lower proportion 48% of the range was
used. Assuming a two-sided alpha error of 0.05, margin of
error of 0.04, and power of 90%, the sample size was 1640.
An additional 10% was added to the above sample size to
compensate for attrition or refusal, resulting in the final
sample size of 1804.
The institutional ethics committee of RD
Gardi Medical College, Ujjain approved the research
protocol. Prior permission was taken from the District
Education Officer and the District Magistrate. Invitations
were sent to the principals or heads of the selected
schools, who reviewed the study design and approved
participation in the study. Informed written assent consent
to participate in the study was obtained from students and
their parents.
A two-stage (schools and classrooms)
cluster sampling was used. Out of the total of 514 higher
secondary schools in Ujjain, 93 schools had 40-50 students
in class 9-12. We selected 30 schools using random numbers.
During second stage sampling, we randomly selected 2002
students of class 9-12 from these schools. Of these, parents
of 1944 children provided consent, and were enrolled for the
study.
Data were collected for six months,
duration from July, 2018 to December, 2018. A structured
questionnaire was developed in English and was then
translated to Hindi as per World Health Organization
recommendations. Forward translation was performed by a
bilingual professional health care worker, namely a
pediatrician who had injury work experience, and an expert
panel resolved any discrepancies in translation [10]. The
questionnaire was back translated to English to ensure that
the original meaning had been retained. Pilot testing of the
questionnaire was performed on 10 school students (aged
15-18 years), and the final version was then produced.
A team of trained research assistants
asked the students to fill-in a questionnaire following
which the educational intervention was administered.
Post-training assessment of students was conducted one-month
later using the same structured questionnaire. Students took
approximately 20 min to complete the questionnaire. The
questionnaire consisted of 25 questions, of which 8 were on
prevention and 17 were on first aid. A score of 1 was given
to each correct answer and the minimum and the maximum score
obtained was 0 and 25, respectively.
Educational intervention: A visit to
each school was scheduled before starting the educational
intervention. The training session used a training module
based on the Red Cross Society first aid module [11]. The
length of an intervention session was 40 min. A total of 120
sessions were conducted in 6 months which included 60
pre-intervention and equal number of post-intervention
sessions. Apart from post-intervention sessions no other
reinforcement was provided to the students. A minimum gap of
one month was maintained between pre- and post-intervention
sessions.
The educational intervention included
lectures on different types of unintentional injuries, such
as burns, poisoning, drowning, suffocation, and physical
injuries (wounds, fractures, and road traffic accidents) and
their first aid through PowerPoint presentations, pictures,
and videos. Other lecture topics in the training included
basic information on the ‘Good Samaritan law’ in India,
importance of the golden hour, and importance and components
of the first aid box. Participants were not informed in the
beginning that they would be tested later.
Fidelity of the intervention: The
intervention design was informed by the theoretical
framework of the infor-mation-motivation-behavioural skills
(IMB) model of health behavior [12]. Further, the research
assistants were trained by the principal investigator to
maintain the fidelity of the intervention. The intervention
module consisted of a 3-hour training session involving a
discussion on all pictures, videos, and each slide in the
power point presentation regarding the content and the way
of delivering the lecture. The concepts were reinforced by
providing the research assistants an opportunity to engage
in role-playing. The session was repeated once every
fortnight during the study period. To ensure the
implementation of the intervention, a training manual was
used to articulate the contents and delivery of the
educational interventions. The participants’ receipts of
intervention were assessed on the basis of their atten-dance
and the acquired knowledge post-intervention.
The main outcome variable (dependent
variable) was the change in pre- and post-intervention
knowledge score. Age, gender, school location, school type,
medium of education in the schools, and the class in which
the students were studying were the main independent
variables.
Statistical analysis: Data were
collected in the schools through paper-based questionnaires
which were reviewed daily by the principal investigator and
co-investigators for consistency and completion. The data
were coded and entered in Epi Info
(Version 7.2). Data analysis was
performed using Stata (Version 16.0, Stata Corp). The data
were analyzed to determine the proportion of correctly
answered questions by students pre- and post-intervention.
Pearson chi-square test was used as a test of significance.
Sum total of knowledge scores before and after intervention
were compared using repeated mea-sures analysis of variance.
To quantify the effectiveness of educational intervention,
an effect size (Cohen’s d) was derived. A multivariate
quantile regression model was used to test the association
between the dependent and independent variables.
Quantile regression model was chosen to
capture the full distribution of the outcome – change in
pre- and post-intervention knowledge scores. The coefficient
(b), standard error, and 95% confidence interval (CI) were
estimated for 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th, and 90th quantiles of
the change in pre- and post-intervention knowledge scores
based on 500 bootstrap samples. A P value <0.05 was
considered significant.
RESULTS
Of the 1944 students, 1105 (57%) were
boys and the remaining 839 (43%) were girls. The mean (SD)
age of the participating students in the study was 15.99
(1.33) years. Table I illustrates the demographic
characteristics of the study participants.
TABLE I Characteristics of School Children Enrolled in the Study (N=1944)
Characteristics |
No. (%) |
Age categories |
|
14-16 years |
1059 (55) |
16-18 years |
760 (39) |
18-20 years |
125 (6) |
Boys |
1105 (57) |
Urban location |
1063 (55) |
Public school |
1165 (60) |
English medium school |
812 (42) |
Grade |
|
9 |
690 (35) |
10 |
513 (26) |
11 |
438 (23) |
12 |
303 (16) |
The mean (SD) pre- and post-intervention
knowledge scores of students were 8.12 (3.59) and
21.31(3.46), respectively. Suppl. Table I
shows the comparison of correct responses related to
knowledge of unintentional injury and first aid. The
difference between the sum total of pre- and
post-intervention scores was statistically significant (P<0.001).
For pre-post intervention know-ledge scores, Cohen’s d
effect size was 3.7, with an effect size
³0.8
defined as large.
Younger students outperformed older
students with most significant association seen at quantiles
q25 [b= -0.28], 95% CI (-0.53 to -0.03), P=0.026],
q75 [b= -0.44, 95% CI (-0.64 to -0.24), P<0.001] and
q90 [b= -0.53, 95% CI (-0.80 to -0.26), P<0.001].
Boys outperformed girls with most significant association
seen at median quantile [b=1.57, 95% CI (0.85 to 2.30), P<0.001].
Students of urban schools outperformed their rural
counterparts across all quantiles (q10, q25, median, q75 and
q90). Students of public schools outperformed the students
of private schools with most significant association seen at
quantile q90 [b= -3.30 (-5.96 to -0.64), P=0.015].
Students of Hindi medium schools performed better than the
students of English medium schools, with most significant
association seen at quantile q10 [b= -4.81, CI (-7.22 to
-2.41), P<0.001].
DISCUSSION
The study findings demonstrated that the
school-based educational intervention significantly
increased the knowledge on the prevention of unintentional
injuries and first aid among adolescents, with a large
effect size. The present study adds to the body of evidence
generated by a systematic review on the effectiveness of a
school-based educational intervention aimed at increasing
the know-ledge of adolescents on unintentional injury prevention
and first aid [8]. Although knowledge of students improved,
but this knowledge does not necessarily lead to
motivational and behavioral changes [13]. The present study
worked on the health promotion information side only.
The results of our study are consistent
with previous first aid educational intervention studies on
adolescents [14]. A study conducted in Australia also
reported that the burn victims receive inadequate first aid
due to inadequate knowledge of the recommended 10-20
minutes time for submerging the burned part in water [15].
In our study, the cardiopulmonary
resuscitation (CPR) knowledge of students significantly
increased following educational intervention. The finding is
consistent with studies conducted in New Zealand and
Australia [15,16]. The Australian study also revealed that a
training program on first aid, CPR, and beach safety offered
to school students enhanced their confidence level in
providing first aid following drowning [16]. India
instituted the ‘Good Samaritan law’ to support bystanders
for helping trauma victims in 2016 [17], and therefore,
students were also educated about the law.
In the present study, younger students
outperformed the older ones. The finding is consistent with
a study on first aid training of preschool children in
Egypt, which reported that age is directly associated with
the first aid knowledge of students [18]. However, another
review from Australia suggests that first aid learning, and
retention of knowledge and skills generally increase with
age and practical training sessions [19].
In the present study, boys outperformed
girls. The finding is contrary to a study in Saudi Arabia
conducted on university students, which reported that
females’ knowledge on CPR and trauma management was superior
to those of male students [20]. Moreover, the performance
of urban school students was found superior to their rural
counterparts in the present study. Another first aid
educational intervention study on the knowledge assessment
of adolescents also reported that the residence
significantly affected the knowledge scores [21].
Further-more, students of public schools outperformed those
of private schools in our study. However, a study conducted
in Ethiopia reported that government school teachers possess
less knowledge and lack appropriate attitude on first aid
compared with private school teachers [22]. In the present
study, students of Hindi medium schools outperformed those
of English medium schools. This might be due to the fact
that students learn better when taught in their mother
tongue [23].
The research team conducting educational
intervention was same in all schools. Random selection of
participants and a robust statistical analysis and multi-variate
quantile regression are also the other merits of our study.
However, lack of external controls, poses a threat to
generalizability of the results. Pre-post design using the
same questionnaire might have allowed some students to
memorize the questions (interaction effect). However, the
students were not aware that a post-test would be done. The
study design allowed the interpretation of results based on
a temporal relationship of measurements with the educational
intervention. Additionally, the study was not designed to
follow-up students for the evaluation of long-term knowledge
retention. We do not currently know the number of
reinforcement sessions needed for long term knowledge
retention among adolescent students, which needs to be
studied in future studies.
We conclude that educational
interventions in school curriculums can strengthen the
knowledge of adolescents on unintentional injury prevention
and first aid. Quality school-based educational trainings
can help raise aware-ness among adolescents.
Note: Supplementary material related
to this study is available with the online version at
www.indianpediatrics.net
Ethics clearance:
Institutional Ethics Committee, RD Gardi Medical College,
Ujjain; IEC-RDGMC 354, January 08, 2014.
Contributors: SM, AM, JJ, AP:
contributed towards the conception and design of the work,
analysis and interpretation of data for the work, drafting
the work or revising it critically for important
intellectual content, and final approval of the version to
be published. All authors agreed to be accountable for all
aspects of the work
Funding: Indian Council of Medical
Research, New Delhi.
Competing interests: None stated.
WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN?
•
School-based intervention
studies improve knowledge of first aid and injury
prevention.
WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS?
•
The study generates data on the effectiveness of
school-based educational intervention in Indian
adolescent children to improve knowledge about first
aid and prevention of unintentional injuries.
|
REFERENCES
1. McGee K, Sethi D, Peden M, Habibula S.
Guidelines for conducting community surveys on injuries and
violence. Int J Inj Contr and Saf Promot. 2004;11:303-6.
2. Vecino-Ortiz AI, Jafri A, Hyder AA.
Effective interventions for unintentional injuries: A
systematic review and mortality impact assessment among the
poorest billion. Lancet Glob Health. 2018;6:e523-34.
3. Uthkarsh PS, Gururaj G, Reddy SS,
Rajanna MS. Assessment and availability of trauma care
services in a district hospital of South India: A field
observational study. Bull Emerg Trauma. 2016;4:93-100.
4. Oestern HJ, Garg B, Kotwal P. Trauma
care in India and Germany. Clin Orthop Relat Res.
2013;471:2869-77.
5. Kasthuri A. Challenges to healthcare
in India - The Five A’s. Indian J Community Med.
2018;43:141-3.
6. Mattila VM, Parkkari J, Koivusilta L,
Nummi T, Kannus P, Rimpelä A. Adolescents health and health
behaviour as predictors of injury death. A prospective
cohort follow-up of 652,530 person-years. BMC Public Health.
2008;8:90.
7. Reveruzzi B, Buckley L, Sheehan M.
School-based first aid training programs: A systematic
review. J Sch Health. 2016; 86:266-72.
8. Government of India. Ujjain district
population census 2011-2020. India. 2020. Accessed May 09,
2020. Available from: https://census2011.co.in/census/
district/302-Ujjain. html
9. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of India. National Family Health Survey-4,
District fact sheet Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh 2015-2016.
Government of India. Accessed May 09, 2020. Available from:
http://rchiips.org/NFHS/FCTS/MP/MP_ FactSheet_435_Ujjain
.pdf
10. World Health Organization. Process of
translation and adaptation of instruments. World Health
Organization; 2020. Accessed May 09, 2020. Available from:
https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/research_tools/translation/en/
11. Canadian Red Cross. Comprehensive
quide for firstaid & CPR [Internet]. Canadian Red Cross;
2017. Accessed May 9, 2020. Available from
http://www.redcross.ca/crc/documents/cmprehensive guide for
firstaid cpr en.pdf
12. Fisher WA, Fisher JD, Harman J. The
information-motivation-behavioral skills model: A general
social psychological approach to understanding and promoting
health behavior. In: Suls JM, Wallston KA, editors.
Social Psychological Foundations of Health and Illness. 1st.
ed. Blackwell Publishing; 2003.p.82-106.
13. Das K, Pal A, Dasgupta A, et al. A
study on the effectiveness of educational intervention
regarding first aid management of selected medical
emergencies among adolescents at a school in Kolkata. Int J
Community Med and Public Health. 2019;7:340-4.
14. Frear CC, Griffin B, Watt K, Kimble
R. Barriers to adequate first aid for paediatric burns at
the scene of the injury. Health Promot J Austr.
2018;29:160-6.
15. Wilks J, Kanasa H, Pendergast D,
Clark K. Beach safety education for primary school children.
Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot. 2017;24:283-92.
16. Parnell MM, Pearson J, Galletty DC,
Larsen PD. Knowledge of and attitudes towards resuscitation
in New Zealand high-school students. Emerg Med
J.2006;23:899-902.
17. Save Life Foundation. Impediments to
Bystander Care in India: National Study on Impact of Good
Samaritan Law. India: Save Life Foundation; 2018. Accessed
May 09, 2020. Available from:
https://savelifefoundation.org/pdfs/Impediments-to-Bystander-Care-in-India-National-Study-on-Impact-of-Good-Samaritan-Law.pdf
18. Elewa AA-A, Saad AM. Effect of child
to child approach educational method on knowledge and
practices of selected first aid measures among primary
school children. J Nurs Educ and Pract. 2017;8:69.
19. Lenson S, Mills J. First aid
knowledge retention in school children: A review of the
literature [Internet]. Australasia J Paramedicine. 2016;13.
20. Ahmad A, Akhter N, Mandal RK, et al.
Knowledge of basic life support among the students of Jazan
university, Saudi Arabia: Is it adequate to save a life?
Alexandria J Med. 2018;54:555-9.
21. Chandrachood MV, Acharya S. A study
to assess the effectiveness of training on first aid among
students of industrial training institute in tribal area of
Thane district, Maharashtra. Int J Community Med and Public
Health. 2019;6:1573-7.
22. Ganfure G, Ameya G, Tamirat A, Lencha
B, Bikila D. First aid knowledge, attitude, practice, and
associated factors among kindergarten teachers of Lideta
sub-city Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. PLoS One. 2018;13:e0194263.
23. Bialystok E. Bilingual education for young children:
review of the effects and consequences. Int J Biling Educ
Biling. 2018;21:666-79.
|
|
 |
|