AN APGAR SCORE OF THREE
OR LESS AT ONE MINUTE IS NOT DIAGNOSTIC OF BIRTH ASPHYXIA BUT IA A USEFUL
SCREENING TEST FOR NEONATAL ENCEPHALOPATHY
M. Ellis, N. Manandhar*, D.S. Manandhar* and A.M. deL Costello
From the Maternal and Infant Research Activities, Kathmandu, Nepal* and the Institute of Child Health, London, United Kingdom.
Reprint requests: Dr. Anthony Costello, Center for International Child Health, Institute of Child Health, 30 Guilford St, London WC1N1EH, United Kingdom.
Manuscript received: September 23, 1997; Initial review completed: October 21, 1997; Revision accepted: December 6, 1997
Objective: To
evaluate the relationship between an Apgar score of three or less at one
minute of life and the subsequent risk of developing neonatal encephalopathy
(NE). Design:
Prospective. Setting:
The principal maternity hospital of Kathmandu, Nepal, a low
income country, where over 50% of the local population deliver. Methods:
All liveborn infants over a 12 month period with a birthweight of 500 g
or more were assessed by the Apgar scoring system at one minute of age.
All term infants with neurological abnormalities presenting in the first
day of life were systematically examined and described according to a conventionally
defined encephalopathy grading system. Major congenital malformations and
neonatal infections were excluded. Results:
Over 12 months there were 14,771 total births of a weight of 500g
or more of which 14,371 were live births and 400 were stillbirths. Of 734
infants with 1 min Apgar of three or less, 91 developed NE. The positive
and negative predictive values of 1 min Apgar of three or less for NE were
11.4% and 99.9%, respectively. The probability of developing NE rose from
0.6% (amongst all infants born at this hospital) to 11.2% (amongst infants
born with a one minute Apgar of three or less). Conclusions:
An Apgar score of 3 or less at one minute is a useful screening
test for clinically significant birth asphyxia (NE). It overestimates by
eight fold the scale of the birth asphyxia problem, but identifies a high
risk group requiring further observation of their neurological condition.
Key words: Apgar, Birth asphyxia, Neonatal encephalopathy.