1.gif (1892 bytes)

Statement

Indian Pediatrics 2004; 41:146-155

Consensus Statement of IAP Working Group: Status Report on Diagnosis of Childhood Tuberculosis  


Correspondence: Dr. Y.K. Amdekar, 151, Tushar, 14th Road, Chembur, Mumbai 400 071, India.
 E-mail: ykakr@vsnl.com


In consonance with the decision of the Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) to standardize protocols for diagnosis and management of common childhood diseases, a meeting of IAP working group on diagnosis of childhood tuberculosis was held at Mumbai on 28th and 29th June 2003 (Annexure). The group deliberated in the light of presentations made based on literature reviewed by the members and concluded that at present only a statement giving the status of the commonly used or available diagnostic modalities can be evolved to help the clinician in day to day practice. Recommendations were standard-ized to suit most of the clinical situations met with in routine practice and to ensure reasonably accurate diagnosis. It is hoped that these recommendations will be implemented by the clinicians at all levels and will help to resolve diversities and confusion hitherto prevailing in the diagnosis of childhood tuberculosis. However special circumstances may merit deviations from the standard recommendations based on individual clini-cianís judgement and experience.

Clinical setting for suspecting active tuberculosis / pulmonary TB

Fever and cough >3 weeks denote need for evaluation for diagnosis of active tuberculosis. Fever should be documented if possible to avoid erroneous reporting by parents. Recent onset of fever and cough is the common presentation. Recurrent fever and cough with normal intervening period is often due to diseases other than tuberculosis. Cough as a predominant symptom without fever is mostly due to hyper reactive airways or asthma.

In addition, recent unexplained loss of weight and appetite favors possibility of active tuberculosis. Unexplained poor weight gain in infancy is relevant but not in older children, as several other common conditions also lead to a poor weight gain. History of contact must be specifically enquired and assessed in terms of activity and infectious nature of the disease. Children in contact with an infectious case are at the greatest risk. (Contact is defined as any child .who lives in a household with an adult taking anti-TB therapy or has taken such a therapy in the past 2 years.) Household contact survey is recommended in a younger child.

Diagnosis is more likely in presence of risk factors such as age <1 year, recent history of measles / whooping cough, failure to thrive, immunocompromized state and steroid therapy. Significant superficial lymphadeno-pathy should be specially looked for, as it is present in 40-50% patients. (Inguninal lymph-nodes >1.5 cm and other superficial lymph-nodes >1 cm in size is considered significant.)

Failure of therapeutic response to an appropriate and adequate antibiotic trial in a symptomatic child supports probability of tuberculosis.Therapeutic trial with anti-TB drugs is not recommended and all attempts must be made to diagnose TB by proper investigations.

Table I summarizes indicators for diag-nosis of tuberculosis.

TABLE I

 Indicators for Diagnosis of Tuberculosis
Symptoms
Descriptor
Exclusions
Specific points
Fever
Recent onset of persistent 
fever >3 weeks Fever can 
be of any type in a child with TB
Recurrent fever

Fever should be documented as
 far as possible.
Cough
Recent onset of cough with
fever is significant
Recurrent / episodic
cough without fever
Recurrent cough / fever with intervening
normal period
is often due to diseases other than TB 
Unexplained
recent loss of
weight / appetite
Recent onset of symptoms
are relevant
 
More relevant in infancy
Nonspecific symptoms due to many 
organic or functional disorders
Contact history

Any adult taking anti-TB
 treatment currently
or in the past 2 years
 
Younger the child more important is 
household contact survey 
Risk factors





Age <1 year / failure to 
thrive / recent measles or
whooping cough /
 immunocompormized state /
steroid therapy

 
In suspicious clinical settings, presence 
of risk factors increase the probability of 
disease.
Enlarged superficial lymphonodes must 
be looked for.
Therapeutic trial of anti-TB drugs is not
 recommended.

 

Tuberculin test (Mantoux test)

1 TU PPD with RT 23 Tween 80 (or 5 TU PPD without Tween 80) is injected intra-dermally and the reaction is read between 48-72 hours. Induration of 10 mm or more in largest diameter is suggestive of natural infection, irrespective of prior BCG vaccination.

Natural infection under 2 years of age is suggestive of recent infection and should be treated accordingly. Beyond 2 years of age, natural infection in association with history of contact or symptoms / signs or presence of risk factors increases the risk of disease.

In case a patient presents late but within 7 days of the test, then any reaction above 10 mm is still considered as a positive test. However, if the reaction is less than 10 mm in these latecomers, then a repeat test needs to be done on the other forearm.

In case of continued search for proper diagnosis, test may be repeated few weeks or months after the first test. Induration of 6 mms or more than previous test results may be suggestive of natural infection.

BCG test is of no value and is not recommended.

Radiology

Ideal chest X-ray is taken in upright position PA view. A well centered good exposure mid inspiratory film is a must for correct interpretation.

Lateral view is useful in case of suspicion.

CT Scan of chest is not routinely required. It is not cost and radiation effective.

Radiological lesion does not confirm etiology of tuberculosis, as there are no patho-gnomonc radiological signs of tuberculosis.

However, in following radiological lesions, diagnosis of tuberculosis is most likely in presence of relevant clinical setting: (i) Miliary lesion; (ii) Unilateral Pleural effusion; (iii) Fibrocaseous cavitory lesions; (iv) Pneumonia with an enlarged mediastinal lymph node; and (v) Caseating lymph nodes on CT Scan.

Persistent pneumonia beyond 4 weeks in a symptomatic child inspite of antibiotic therapy may suggest probable TB.

In a child with confirmed diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis, chest x-ray usually be repeated at the end of intensive phase (usually after 2 months of initial treatment) to assess response, unless indicated otherwise in an individual case. In case of deterioration or absence of clinical improvement, chest X-ray should be repeated at the end of 2-3 weeks as needed. Every child should have a final X-ray at the end of treatment.

USG chest is rarely required except in case of a suspected pleural effusion not evident on plain chest X-ray.

Right upper lobe bacterial non-tuberculous pneumonia in an infant often persists with radiological shadow for >4-6 weeks but in such situation, child is clinically normal with appropriate antibiotic therapy. Such a child does not need further evaluation for tuberculosis especially in absence of any risk factors.

Bacteriology

Bacteriology is possible in childhood tuberculosis and may yield positive results in 30-40% of the patients. Hence attempt at bacteriological diagnosis should be made in every patient. Gastric lavage may be used when sputum is not available. Yield increases if multiple samples are examined. Ideally, 3 sputum or gastric aspirate samples should be tested in each case. Vancomycin added to the sample prevents growth of other bacteria and thus improves the yield. Bacteriological confirmation is easy in cavitory lesion and is mandatory in suspected case of multi-drug resistant tuberculosis.

Bactec can offer faster results within 7-8 days but does not increase chances of finding bacteria.

PCR

Results of PCR test depends upon generation of the probe used and some studies suggest that using two probes may be better. Sensitivity of PCR is variable in pulmonary tuberculosis and it may be as low as 20% in gastric aspirate. Hence at present, routine use of PCR is not recommended.

However, its sensitivity and specificity in CSF and pleural fluid may be high and thus it may be considered in suspected case of neuro-tuberculosis.

Serology

Due to many variable factors in host, mycobacterium and environment, serology is not useful in childhood TB. The sensitivity, specificity as well as predictive value of commercially available serological tests at present such as ELISA for TB does not justify their use in our settings.

CBC / ESR

CBC / ESR has no value in either diagnosis or follow up of childhood tuberculosis. ESR is a test, which is influenced by several factors including those extraneous to the patient and disease, therefore, is not recommended.

Table II summarizes the laboratory tests for diagnosis of tuberculosis.

Please click here for
Table II

TB lymphadenitis

Superficial lymphadenopathy is consi-dered significant if it is >1.5 cm in size in inguinal region and >1 cm in cervical and axillary region. Matted lymphnodes favor diagnosis of tuberculosis. Failure of response to antibiotic therapy beyond 2 weeks is highly suggestive of tuberculosis in presence of other supportive features.

Generalized lymphadenopathy is patho-logical irrespective of size of glands. In case of suspected TB lymphadenitis, diagnosis must be confirmed by histopathology. FNAC is an easy and simple procedure of choice in lymphnode disease. It has high sensitivity and specificity. The aspirate can be stained for AFB. AFB can be demonstrated in a good proportion of aspirates particularly if the aspirate is caseous or necrotic. Excision biopsy is rarely required.

Reactive hyperplasia is not a feature of TB lymphadenopathy.

Isolated axillary lymphnode enlargement in an infant (on left side) is due to BCG vaccine and does not warrant treatment even if histopathology or bacteriology suggests TB.

Abdominal TB

Clinical presentation may be in the form of ascitis, subacute intestinal obstruction or pyrexia of unknown origin with or without hepatosplenomegaly.

Barium meal follow through showing pulled up caecum is suggestive of tuberculosis.

Abdominal USG may show significantly enlarged lymphnodes or peritoneal fluid. Presence of small lymphnodes and / or peritoneal fluid is often a finding that needs careful follow-up and should not be considered enough for diagnosis.

Serum albumin ascitic gradient <1.1 favors diagnosis of tuberculosis. Liver biopsy may be helpful in case of hepatomegaly.

Intracranial TB

In TB meningitis, early diagnosis in stage 1 is very important and is suggested by: (a) Fever without localization >2 weeks And/or Altered behavior / change in personality of recent origin; (b) Headache, vomiting sugges-tive of raised intracranial tension; (c) Movement disorder; (d) Focal deficits; (e) Seizures.

Global encephalopathy with focal deficit is hallmark of TBM.

CSF must be examined in every such case. In case of inconclusive results, it should be repeated 48-72 hours after antibiotic therapy and if it shows no change in clinical status and CSF results, then it may favor diagnosis of TBM. CSF glucose must be interpreted in conjunction with simultaneous blood glucose level. CSF smear and culture are negative in 90% of cases. CSF antigen tests are reported to be useful but are not available. CSF antibody tests are not recommended due to poor sensitivity, specificity and predictive value. CSF ADA may suggest diagnosis of tuber-culosis only in presence of other supportive tests but not per se. CSF PCR is also variable.

Mantoux test is negative in 70% of patients.

CT scan is useful and should be considered if possible. Hydrocephalus and basal exudates are seen in 80-100% patients. Normal CT scan does not rule out TBM.

Differentiating inflammatory granulomas such as Tuberculoma and Neurocysticercosis is difficult. However, following points may be used to differentiate the two; (a) Tuberculomas are larger and usually multiple. (b) They are more common in posterior fossa unlike cysticercus granuloma at the gray-white junction; (c) MR spectroscopy may be useful as it shows lipid peaks with tuberculoma.

TB in special situations

HIV and TB

In HIV serological positive but immuno-competent patients, manifestations of tuber-culosis are similar to those seen in general population.

In HIV positive and immunosuprressed patients, tuberculosis is florid, drug reactions are common and therapeutic paradox is known.

Pathognomic X-ray findings are: (i) Confluent patchy consolidation involving more than half lung; (ii) Dense lobar / segmen-tal collapse; (iii) Massive paratracheal / hilar lymphadenopathy; (iv) Concomitant bronchiecctasis.

Mantoux test with 5 mm of reaction is considered significant in immuno-compro-mised patients though it is often negative.

Management of HIV with TB needs specialized expertise and hence referral to tertiary center is recommended.

MDR TB

Drug resistant TB is rare in children. It should be considered when child has a contact with MDR TB or in case of failure of response to adequate treatment for 8-12 weeks. Before considering diagnosis of MDR TB, diagnosis of TB itself should be reviewed. Diagnosis of MDR should be confirmed by bacteriology and patient ideally be managed in a referral center.

Congenital TB

If mother is suffering from active disease during pregnancy, search for TB in a neonate is mandatory. Clinical presentation may be in the form of hepatomegaly or pulmonary / disseminated lesion. Diagnostic criteria remain similar.

Table III is a summary of localised TB and TB in special situations.

Please click here for
Table III

Scoring systems

Evaluation of some available scoring systems has been found to have high sensitivity but low specificity, which may lead to over-diagnosis and unnecessary treatment of non-TB patients. These are not recommen-ded for diagnosis currently, but further research could be undertaken to evaluate the existing scoring charts in the Indian context. Table I provides some helpful indicators for diagnosis of tuberculosis.

Acknowledgement

The meeting was supported from a grant by Sandoz Business Unit, Novartis India Limited for this specific purpose.

Annexure

IAP Committee for framing Guidelines for the Management of Tuberculosis in Children. Following members participated in the meeting:

Y.K. Amdekar (Chairman of the Committee), H.P.S. Sachdev, M.K.C. Nair, Dilip Mukherjee, Nitin K. Shah, Arun Sangani, Arun Kumar Agrawal, A. Bala-chandran, A.P. Dubey, N. Gothi, R.P. Khubchandani, M.A. Mathew, Ravi Rama-kantha, Raju C. Shah, Meenu Singh, Surjit Singh, Varinder Singh, S.P. Srivastava, Soumya Swaminathan, Vrajesh Udani, D. Vijayasekaran, Ashish Mahaukar (Rapporteur).

Members who could not attend:

Elizabeth John, T Jacob John, Sushil Kabra, A.M.D. Motiwala, Vimlesh Sheth, T.U. Sukumaran.

Home

Past Issue

About IP

About IAP

Feedback

Links

 Author Info.

  Subscription